After showing our teacher the rough cut of our production, she had a talk with us about what was good about the production and what could do with some adjustments. Once we had been told what she thought, Miss gave us a feedback sheet that she had filled out with notes on what was good and what needs improving, here are the notes.
Holding a shot steady
The first zoom out on Ashley needs re-doing as it is noticeably jerky. This could also be sorted out by doing a montage of shots, cutting out the jerky bits so it looks like it has been done for a different effect.
Appropriate material
Here a comment suggested we should link the beat at the start with a link to a suitable visual.
The corridor shot needs to be more obviously strange.
Approaching the pump house near the meads needed to be more significant and interesting.
The last shot of approaching Ashley's house was "boring" and needs to be changed.
Selecting mise en scene
Miss had noted she like the noir shadow as Ash leaves his bed.
The surreal pictures were a good idea but aren't very obvious to the viewer.
The last shot is good however Ash could possibly be covered with a sheet for more impact.
Editing for meaning
It has been noted that the music should start after our introduction captions to the examiner.
We should stress the opening of Ashley's eyes more in the opening.
We need to add in our sound effects of the heart rate monitor.
The sitting down at the table needs to be shortened down a little.
The transition to the corridor scene was good but more needs to be done by maybe fading the scene into the piece of paper just before hand.
Varied shot transitions, caption and other FX
We should maybe try out an original idea we had back in pre-production where Ashley is walking in one direction and a passer by is walking in another.
Possibly film so leaves falling off a tree then reverse the footage
Use of sound with images/ editing
Some good ideas
Overall comment
"Good overall idea, but some shots lack impact - go for more strangeness/ weirdness, build uup uncertainty in viewer - can they trust what they are seeing, colour in last shot is good, use spot colour at other points."